It might seem that Aaron
Rodgers and Russell Wilson have and can have nothing in common. All the more
surprising is that people so different in character turn out to be very similar
professionally.
Rodgers and Wilson won the
Super Bowl, but did so back in the last decade. In both cases, it seemed like
the first title of many to come. Rodgers had never made it to the finals since
that win, and Wilson hadn't even come close to a final game since his
interception of a pass in the 2015 Super Bowl.
Since then, the years have
gone by and the star quarterbacks have become increasingly unhappy with winless
seasons. In the offseason, both finally announced it openly, prompting a
mountain of discussion about their future fates.
Probably deserves more than a last minute thrown together between quarter wave. Coach is a legend, and the reason myself and so many came and thrived @Cal #MyCoach #RespectForALegend #GoBears https://t.co/mU49tBWklN
— Aaron Rodgers (@AaronRodgers12) October 30, 2021
Last Sunday, Rodgers and
Wilson met on the field in a regular season game. Both quarterbacks returned to
the game after being forced to "rest": Rodgers tested positive for
coronavirus and was quarantined for a week, while Wilson missed three weeks due
to a broken finger. Both quarterbacks looked uninspiring in the game, which the
Packers won 17-0, a result that put Green Bay in first place in the NFC
standings at 8-2, while the Seahawks' chances of making the playoffs dropped to
16 percent.
It's been 10 weeks into the
regular season, but Wilson and Rodgers' future is still as shrouded in fog as
it was before the season started. Perhaps even more questions have emerged.
In the offseason,
everything indicated that the 2021 season would be Rodgers' last with the
Packers. He hinted that he was in for a "last dance" (similar to the
HBO series about Michael Jordan's final season with the Chicago Bulls) and also
gave a half-hour press conference in which he spoke frankly about his dissatisfaction
with club policy and management. Insiders reported that Rodgers' relationship
with general manager Brian Gutekanst was permanently damaged, and the
quarterback himself did not rule out that he was about to retrain as a
broadcaster.
This is bigger than any game… #NationalChampionsMovie. Theaters only. Coming December 10th.
— Russell Wilson (@DangeRussWilson) November 16, 2021
Grateful to be a part of this one 🙏🏾 https://t.co/ODLE26BKEO
Wilson's complaints were less like a desire to get a divorce, more like a desire to influence the development of the club. His plan worked, as it included both denying the exchange request on one side and making a list of teams to move to on the other. In February, Wilson said he was tired of getting hit -- the Seahawks traded for guard Gabe Jackson and extended his contract. Wilson insisted that his opinion be considered in selecting an offensive coordinator -- and Seattle took Rams assistant Shane Waldron, who was approved by the quarterback's personal coach, for the job.
Fortunately for Wilson, his
plan worked. Unfortunately for the Seahawks, it didn't pay much dividends for
the team. The season was going downhill for Seattle even before the injury to
their starting point guard. The team's offense stagnated, and the work of its
new offensive coordinator was criticized. Wilson coach Jake Heaps even claimed
that the Seahawks' lackluster offense was the reason receiver Odell Beckham
decided not to sign with the team.
Yes, these complaints are
not coming from Wilson personally, but this man is from his inner circle. And
it's hard to imagine Wilson waking up Monday in a good mood after suffering his
first career shutout and a 13.0 quarterback rating.
If Rodgers' departure
seemed more likely before the season, things have changed now. After the game
against Bearcats in Week 6, Rodgers disagreed that it was his last visit to
Soldier Field. He also opined that the Packers' current roster is similar to
the 2010 team that won the Super Bowl. Rodgers, it turns out, is a simple man -
if the team wins and contends for a championship, he's fine with it. Plus,
Green Bay management went to his head and traded receiver Randall Cobb at
Rodgers' personal request.
Things are different at
Seattle, though it's hard to blame management alone. The team has indulged
Wilson in many ways over the past two seasons. This has particularly affected
the reorientation of the offense toward the pass - the team has become 5th in
the league in frequency of pass shenanigans on early downs. That approach
worked for two months, until opponents adjusted to the Seahawks' new philosophy
and turned Wilson from an MVP contender into a middle infielder.
What conclusion did Pete
Carroll draw? The team lacks carry, of course! Waldron was expected to put a
fresh offense in Seattle that would give Wilson all the tools he needed to play
great. His appointment seemed to be a compromise between Carroll and Wilson --
motions before shenanigans and high tempo play for the quarterback, zone
takeout for the head coach. Everyone is happy, and fans were eagerly awaiting
the start of the season.
Two months later, Waldron's
offense looks more like that of the first offensive coordinator under Wilson,
Darrell Bevell. That's not so surprising, since the rookie coordinator has had
to adapt to the characteristics of his point guard's game.
One of Wilson's key traits
is that he doesn't throw to the center of the floor, especially at mid-range.
Perhaps it's a matter of height. Or maybe Wilson isn't comfortable targeting
players in tight coverage in a crowd of defenders. Either way, it's become an
issue this season.
Here's a heat map of passes
played by Wilson. On the left are all the routes played by Seattle's receivers,
and on the right are where he throws the ball most often.
It's not news that Wilson
avoids throwing to center field, so Waldron had to adjust to him. The problem
is that the entire structure of the offense that Waldron preaches is based on
playing through the center. These principles are what made Jared Goff look like
a man and a decent pass rusher for the Rams, and Stafford plays at the level of
an MVP contender. But in McVay's new version of the offense, that aspect has
been lost -- Seattle ranks last in the league in pass rushers using at least
one route oriented to the center of the field. Wilson has thrown only 28
passes, and nearly all of those mid-range passes have been to D.K. Metcalfe,
who, because of his size, generally has a hard time executing such routes.
Wilson also affects the
format of the team's takeout game. Sean McVay's offense, which Waldron is
trying to replicate in the Seahawks, is built around specific principles that
work much better if the quarterback gets the ball from the center hand-to-hand.
But Wilson feels better off the sidelines, in a shotgun formation, so Waldron
is once again caught between two evils. In the 2020 season, the Rams ranked
30th in the league in frequency of shotgun use. In five games with Wilson in
2021, the Seahawks were ranked 16th in the NFL in that metric and have already
ordered more shotgun takeaways than Los Angeles did all of last year.
This trait was particularly unfortunate in the game against the Packers -- Wilson was physically unable to take the ball directly from center because of a finger injury, so the Seahawks used the pistol, a truncated version of the shotgun, to make plays that are designed to play from the short snap. That goes a long way toward explaining why Seattle was so early in the game.
gave up an away game, and Wilson threw 40
assists in his first game after injury.
The Seahawks didn't play in Green Bay what
they called Waldron for. And resolving that situation can be difficult because
Wilson is a terrible match for his principles. The coaching change helped
Rodgers, who got a second wind after appointing Matt Lafleur to replace Mike
McCarthy. But Rodgers' combination of skills didn't go against Lafleur's ideas,
so they found common ground. But whether Wilson can seriously change to adjust
to an unfamiliar offense is a big question. And is it even worth asking him to
do so? After all, Wilson is the one with years of playing at the highest level,
while Waldron is a freshman with no previous accomplishments. A new coordinator
is easier to find than a quarterback of Wilson's caliber.
"The Packers went after Rodgers and it
worked. "The Seahawks tried to do the same thing with Wilson, but got
rather negative results. And we're in for a sequel to last offseason's hits
this summer.